The two disasters were a blow from which the company never really recovered. The rae also reconstructed about twothirds of galyp at farnborough and found fatigue crack growth from a rivet hole at the. We get to the bottom of it in this mysteries of flight article. One year later, however, a comet broke apart after taking off from calcutta airport. The metal fatigue was not only due to the pressure factor, but also due to lift, gravitational pull, drags, repeated landing impacts, thrust, turbulence, and sudden erratic maneuvers in midair which all contributed to metal fatigue. Comet jetliner brings you the full and authentic experience of flying british aviations most iconic jetliner. In an age of propellers, this britishmade jet had four turbojet. A technological leap forward, the comet ushered in the jet age, significantly reduced travel times and dramatically increased passenger comfort. When early comets suffered from catastrophic depressurization. Imagine introducing a hole into the centre of an object. In modern terms, it was an executive transport, aimed at wealthy private individuals, often. Why you wouldnt want to fly the first jet airliner.
However, two accidents in 1954 grounded the comet fleet and the subsequent investigation has ensured that the dehavilland comet disaster remains a notorious example of metal fatigue failure. In the meantime, the american aircraft manufacturer, boeing, had. A comet leaving calcutta disintegrated in a thunderstorm. The dramatic effect of subcritical crack growth by fatigue on the mechanical integrity of aircraft. There were 29 passengers and six crew members on board. Two more crashes followed before engineers traced the problem. The comet 1 was of allmetal construction, with a wing featuring a leadingedge sweep of 20 degrees, straight tail surfaces, and tricycle landing gear. So the engineers did a huge fatigue test of an actual airplane. It was put into service six years earlier, in 1952.
The aircraft, registered galyp, had taken off shortly before from ciampino airport in rome. The approximate 7,000 mile 11,265 kilometer flight was expected to take 23 hours, 40 minutes with intermediate stops at rome, beirut, khartoum, entebbe and livingstone. Its introduction into boac service in may 1952 was greeted as the dawning of a new age in passenger travel. The airplane operated on a flight from romaciampino airport cia to london airport lhr.
The comet crashed into the sea near elba island, off the italian coast, killing all 35 people on board. David warren to invent the now familiar cockpit voice recorders and flight data recorders for civil aircraft. They were amplified by the high speed and altitude the comets were operated. There were nine passengers and nine crew members on board. The investigation explored a number of avenues, and finally gave structural failure of the pressure cabin brought about by fatigue as the cause of the accidents. The tragedies that changed the shape of plane windows forever.
With such a clean sheet design, there will still lessons to learn. History of jet flight and the issue of metal fatigue. But the investigators still needed to establish why that first crack had appeared. The most dramatic of these saw one of the airliners breakup in midflight. The design was tested using the techniques available at the time and fatigue was accounted for by testing a section of cabin structure.
It was designed and built in hatfield, hertfordshire, united kingdom in 1949. The root of this rapid failure due to metal fatigue was shown to be high stresses around cutouts, such as windows, in the aircraft skin. After 3000 pulsations a crack appeared near a cabin window and quickly spread. The skin of yoke uncle had undergone 3057 flight cycles 1221 actual and 1836 simulated before a fatigue crack produced a failure. This fact was not taken into consideration when the comet was designed and built. This occurred at a rivet hole near the forward port escape hatch. The aircraft tookoff from hatfield aerodrome and flew for 31 minutes with harold waters as copilot, john wilson and frank reynolds as flight engineers and tony fairbrother as the test observer. The major overseas airlines of the early fifties were boac and pan am. The airplane operated on a flight from genevecointrin airport gva to nicecote dazur airport nce. As world war ii was winding down, the british government convened a commission to explore how the advances in aviation during the war could be. Lessons from some of the biggest hardware screwups. The dehavilland comet crash aerospace engineering blog.
The original design of the comet aircraft had square windows a bad design. In modern terms, it was an executive transport, aimed at wealthy private individuals, often via the companies they owned. On the 2nd of may, 1953, boac flight 783 took off from what was then called dum dum airport in calcutta. Bursting into flames just before takeoff in rome season finale real audio duration. Flights were temporarily voluntarily suspended, then resumed. As the cabin pressurizes, it puts extreme pressure on the airframe, which is concentrated at right angles. Metal fatigue was recognized as being the cause of the issue.
It was developed specifically to participate in the 1934 englandaustralia macrobertson air race from the united kingdom to australia. Boac ordered british made comets, pan am bought american made constellations, dc4s and then 707s, dc8s and convair 880s. But disaster struck the comet after one year of service. Metals will break under a load which is repeatedly applied and then. They varied the cabin pressure hydraulically while they flexed the wings. Then, on october 26, 1952, a comet leaving rome ran off the runway and skidded to a halt with a broken. Although the designers knew about metal fatigue, they had not fully understood how. On investigation it was found a crack had developed at a bolthole in an. It had a number of new features which are now accepted as part of modern aircraft design, but at the time set a completely new trend. The comet design was finalized in 1945, as the british aircraft industry was attempting to establish a commercial aircraft industry postworld war ii. A court of inquiry was convened, and the task of discovering the cause of these accidents was given to the royal aircraft establishment at farnborough.
A number of technical advances had to be made to enable the aircraft to fly, and these stretched the scientific knowledge of the time to the limit. The yp and yy crashes were due to metal fatigue, which took place because of the crystalline changes in the fuselage skin. The comets design made use of aluminums greater strengthtoweight ratio seven models of the comet were produced, starting. Originally designed to house 101 passengers, as a charter airliner in its later life it had a capacity of 119. Aircraft windows and doors are round to prevent metal fatigue.
The entire forward fuselage section was tested for metal fatigue by repeatedly pressurising to 2. Previous aircraft, mostly military designs from the second world war, had used steel. For several months the aircraft led the world by halving journey times and offering comfort levels which could not be matched on other pistonengined aircraft. The crashes were found to be caused by metal fatigue. This accurate simulation of the dh 106 comet 4c features fully equipped pilot and copilot panels, a complete engineers station and also a navigators station. This reign however was short lived when disaster struck on january 10 th 1954. The comet was one of the first pressurized commercial aircraft, and once the catastrophic metal fatigue problem was solved it offered passengers a very comfortable flight. Obviously metal fatigue itself wasnt a new phenomenon. After the conclusive evidence revealed in the inquiry that metal fatigue concentrated at the corners of the aircrafts windows had caused the crashes, all aircraft were redesigned with rounded windows. The comet was the first commercial transonic passenger jet, and also pioneered the use of new aluminum alloys in the airframe.
519 111 1069 947 483 1340 1321 148 1052 817 1379 333 1052 833 1169 329 704 100 908 545 304 837 386 71 755 1259 580 949 256 967 275 223 1216 1335 493 1475 1337 173 935 145 1486 301 1446 1261 448 1034